-
Scottish government to release legal advice on Salmond court action

Move comes after it emerged deputy first minister, John Swinney, faced cross-party censure
John Swinney, Scotland’s deputy first minister, has agreed to release his government’s legal advice on Alex Salmond’s court action after facing cross-party censure in Holyrood.
Swinney told the Holyrood committee investigating the Salmond controversy on Monday night it would get the advice on Tuesday afternoon, after it emerged all four opposition parties would back a Conservative no-confidence motion in him tabled for later on Tuesday.
It remains unclear whether the advice will be released publicly once it has been given to the committee. Swinney told MSPs he had agreed, because of the “exceptional circumstances”, he would release the papers “to the committee and for publication” but the Tories accused him of prevarication.
The Tories said the advice should be published for everyone to see, and would not lift the threat of a no-confidence vote until they had seen what Swinney did and how extensive the disclosures were.
“The deputy first minister is not in the clear yet,” said Douglas Ross, the Scottish Tory leader. “He must go further and fully publish the legal advice or we will not hesitate to force him out.”
The legal advice, written in October 2018 by one of Scotland’s most senior lawyers, Roddy Dunlop QC, is said to have warned the government it was likely to lose Salmond’s legal challenge over its flawed internal inquiry into sexual harassment complaints against him.
It had emerged the civil servant who led that inquiry had spoken to both women before they made their complaints official, briefing them on the new anti-harassment policy before it was complete and approved.
That apparent conflict of interest led to Salmond winning his court challenge in early January 2019, when the government conceded its inquiry was flawed, unlawful and had the appearance of bias.
Dunlop, now dean of the Faculty of Advocates, the ruling body for advocates, Scotland’s equivalent to a barrister, and his junior, are said to have threatened resignation later in 2018 because Leslie Evans, the government’s permanent secretary, was refusing to concede.
After rejecting two previous demands by Holyrood to do so, Swinney said he would release that advice to the committee in part to counter inaccurate allegations about what it said.
“The very integrity of the legal system is being questioned,” he said. “Serious allegations have been made. This material allows people to confirm that these allegations are false.”
With Nicola Sturgeon due to give evidence on oath to the committee on Wednesday morning, the relevance of that advice intensified sharply when Salmond testified last week that Sturgeon was involved in discussions about what to do with it.
Salmond told the committee: “Everything about that legal advice,even how it has been described in terms, suggests that, on the balance of probabilities, it indicated that the government was about to lose.
“
Salmond suggested Sturgeon could be guilty of a breach of the ministerial code if that advice was ignored, because it increased the legal costs and delay. Salmond was eventually awarded £512,000 in legal costs, a substantial figure calculated partly to reflect the fact the government had unnecessarily prolonged the court action.
The committee is again questioning the lord advocate, James Wolffe QC, on Tuesday morning, along with crown agent David Harvie.
Wolffe began his evidence by robustly rejecting cover-up claims, including assertions from Salmond last week, allegations from some opposition MSPs and on social media, or that the Crown Office had been politically influenced or biased in its decisions.
Salmond is furious the Crown Office refuses to release evidence he says proves collusion by senior figures in the Scottish National party to get him prosecuted, and also that it asked Holyrood to heavily edit one of his submissions.
Wolffe said all Crown Office decisions were based on the law, and independent of any outside influence. He said David Harvie, the crown agent who is the Crown Office’s head of prosecutions, was an “exceptional public servant” and a man of utmost integrity.
“Any suggestion from any quarter that the Crown’s decision making has at any time been influenced by political considerations or improper motivations would be wholly without foundation. Insinuations and assertions to the contrary are baseless,” he said.
source: Severin Carrell
Levant
You May Also Like
Popular Posts
Caricature
BENEFIT Sponsors BuildHer...
- April 23, 2025
BENEFIT, the Kingdom’s innovator and leading company in Fintech and electronic financial transactions service, has sponsored the BuildHer CityHack 2025 Hackathon, a two-day event spearheaded by the College of Engineering and Technology at the Royal University for Women (RUW).
Aimed at secondary school students, the event brought together a distinguished group of academic professionals and technology experts to mentor and inspire young participants.
More than 100 high school students from across the Kingdom of Bahrain took part in the hackathon, which featured an intensive programme of training workshops and hands-on sessions. These activities were tailored to enhance participants’ critical thinking, collaborative problem-solving, and team-building capabilities, while also encouraging the development of practical and sustainable solutions to contemporary challenges using modern technological tools.
BENEFIT’s Chief Executive Mr. Abdulwahed AlJanahi, commented: “Our support for this educational hackathon reflects our long-term strategic vision to nurture the talents of emerging national youth and empower the next generation of accomplished female leaders in technology. By fostering creativity and innovation, we aim to contribute meaningfully to Bahrain’s comprehensive development goals and align with the aspirations outlined in the Kingdom’s Vision 2030—an ambition in which BENEFIT plays a central role.”
Professor Riyadh Yousif Hamzah, President of the Royal University for Women, commented: “This initiative reflects our commitment to advancing women in STEM fields. We're cultivating a generation of creative, solution-driven female leaders who will drive national development. Our partnership with BENEFIT exemplifies the powerful synergy between academia and private sector in supporting educational innovation.”
Hanan Abdulla Hasan, Senior Manager, PR & Communication at BENEFIT, said: “We are honoured to collaborate with RUW in supporting this remarkable technology-focused event. It highlights our commitment to social responsibility, and our ongoing efforts to enhance the digital and innovation capabilities of young Bahraini women and foster their ability to harness technological tools in the service of a smarter, more sustainable future.”
For his part, Dr. Humam ElAgha, Acting Dean of the College of Engineering and Technology at the University, said: “BuildHer CityHack 2025 embodies our hands-on approach to education. By tackling real-world problems through creative thinking and sustainable solutions, we're preparing women to thrive in the knowledge economy – a cornerstone of the University's vision.”
opinion
Report
ads
Newsletter
Subscribe to our mailing list to get the new updates!